Passing your driving test is an exhilarating milestone, promising freedom, independence, and a fresh chapter on the open road. Yet, for many newly qualified drivers in the UK, the excitement can quickly be tempered by the sobering reality of expensive car insurance premiums. “Why is insurance so expensive for new drivers?” is a question that echoes through countless conversations, forums, and family kitchens. If you’re new behind the wheel and searching for answers—and more importantly, solutions—this article will walk you through the key factors behind those daunting costs and share smart strategies for saving money while staying covered.
Why Is Car Insurance So High for New Drivers?
There are many reasons why new drivers face higher insurance premiums. One of the most common reasons why car finance is so expensive is due to a lack of driving experience. Studies by Brake, the Road Safety Charity, show that 1 in 5 drivers have crashes within their first year of driving. This imposes a higher risk to the insurance companies, who, in turn, set their premiums higher for new drivers. However, there are also other factors insurers consider when setting the price of cover.
Lack of Driving Experience.
Insurance providers base their prices on risk, and unfortunately, new drivers are statistically at higher risk of being involved in accidents. Without a track record to prove safe driving habits, insurers must rely on general data. According to the Association of British Insurers, drivers aged 17-24 are almost twice as likely to make an insurance claim as older motorists. The lack of experience means insurance companies often prepare for the worst-case scenario, resulting in higher premiums.
Age and Young Driver Surcharge.
Most new drivers are young, typically between 17 and 25 years old. This age group is considered the riskiest by insurers since they’re more likely to take driving risks, lack road awareness, or be involved in collisions. Data shows that young drivers are disproportionately represented in accident statistics. Even if you’re a mature new driver, you’ll still face elevated premiums due to your lack of driving history, but youthful drivers often get the highest bills.
Car Choice and Engine Size.
It can be tempting to pick a car that’s sleek, sporty, or has a powerful engine—after all, you’ve earned it! However, insurers look at the make, model, and engine size of your car. High-performance vehicles or those in higher insurance groups cost more to repair or are more likely to be involved in high-speed incidents. Even small differences in engine capacity can have a big impact on your quote. Generally, cars with smaller engines, fewer modifications, and robust safety features will attract lower premiums.
Type of Cover.
There are three main types of car insurance in the UK: third-party only, third-party fire and theft, and comprehensive cover. While it might seem logical that third-party cover would be cheapest (since it offers the least protection), that’s not always the case. Many insurers view drivers who opt for minimum coverage as higher risk, which can sometimes result in surprisingly high premiums. Comprehensive coverage can sometimes be cheaper—plus, it provides broader protection.
Claims History and No Claims Discount.
Insurance companies reward history. If you’ve never held a policy before, you don’t have a “no claims discount,” which can significantly reduce premiums over time. New drivers start from scratch, so you’ll be paying the full price until you build up a safe driving record.
Additional Drivers and Usage.
Who else drives your car? Adding an experienced driver (like a parent) to your policy can sometimes lower the cost, but if you’re the main driver, the risk assessment still falls on you. How you use your car also matters—commuting in rush hour is riskier than weekend leisure drives, so insurers may adjust your premium accordingly.
Top Tips for Cheaper Car Insurance:
Having a valid insurance premium in place is a legal requirement for all UK drivers. So, unfortunately, there’s no getting away from higher premiums. While it’s true that insurance for new drivers is expensive, there are clever ways to cut costs without compromising on cover. Knowing how car insurance works and the factors insurers consider can help you to be strategic about your insurance rates.
1. Choose Your Car Wisely.
Did you know the type of car you choose can affect your car insurance rates? Stick to cars in lower insurance groups, with smaller engines, and lots of safety features. Popular models among new drivers include the Ford Fiesta, Vauxhall Corsa, and Volkswagen Polo. You should also avoid cars with modifications or modifying the car yourself, as they can hike your premiums.
2. Consider Telematics (Black Box) Insurance.
Telematics or “black box” insurance involves fitting a device in your car that monitors your driving habits—speed, braking, cornering, and times of travel. Safe drivers can see substantial discounts, as insurers have direct data to base their risk profile on. Black box policies are especially popular with young UK drivers and can be a game-changer for your wallet.
3. Add an Experienced Named Driver.
Adding a parent or older relative who has a good driving record as a named driver on your policy can reduce your premium. However, it’s crucial not to put someone else as the main driver if they’re not—this is called “fronting” and is considered insurance fraud.
4. Build Your No Claims Discount.
No claims discount is a reduction to your insurance based on each year you don’t make a claim. You will not be eligible for a no-claims discount during your first year of driving; however, you may begin to accumulate a no-claims history thereafter. Drive carefully and avoid making claims—each year you don’t claim, you’ll accrue a no-claims discount, which can dramatically lower your premium over time. Consider policies that allow you to protect your no-claims bonus, even if you do have to claim.
5. Pay Annually If You Can.
If you’re able, pay your insurance premium in one annual lump sum. This avoids interest charges and can save you a surprising amount compared to monthly payments.
6. Increase Your Excess.
When you’re making an insurance application, you’ll be asked how much voluntary excess you want to pay. Opting for a higher voluntary excess (the amount you pay towards any claim) can reduce your premium. However, just make sure you set it at a level you can afford, should you need to claim.
7. Shop Around and Compare Quotes.
Loyalty doesn’t always pay with insurance. Use price comparison car insurance websites, such as Compare the Market or MoneySuperMarket and be sure to check multiple providers and look for exclusive deals. Don’t auto-renew without checking—you could save hundreds of pounds simply by shopping around.
8. Consider Advanced Driving Courses.
Completing an advanced driving course, such as Pass Plus, can show insurers you’re committed to safe driving. Some providers offer discounts to drivers who have these additional qualifications.
Car insurance for new drivers in the UK may feel unfairly expensive, but understanding the factors at play puts you in a stronger position to save. By choosing your car wisely, exploring telematics options, adding experienced named drivers, and shopping around for the best deals, you can take meaningful steps to reduce your premium. Above all, focus on building a safe driving record—over time, your costs will fall, and you’ll enjoy greater freedom on the road.
Ready to get behind the wheel without breaking the bank? With these tips, you can drive confidently, knowing you’re covered—and smarter about your insurance choices.
Looking for Car Finance for First-Time Drivers?
Are you a newly-qualified driver looking for car finance? We can help you through the process!